Legal holds: what to preserve, and when to release
Over-preserving is expensive and under-preserving is dangerous. A practical approach to scoping and releasing holds.
eDiscovery · Daniel Archer · September 12, 2026

The duty to preserve starts when litigation is reasonably anticipated, not when a claim is filed. That timing is where many organisations get into trouble.
Scope by custodian and date
Identify the people likely to hold relevant information and the period that matters. Preserving everything for everyone feels safe, but it multiplies review costs and can itself become a problem in discovery.
Cover every source
Email is the obvious one. Chat, shared drives, collaboration tools and phones are where relevant material increasingly lives. A hold that misses Slack or Teams is not a complete hold.
Notify and track acknowledgement
Custodians need to know what to keep and confirm they understand. Send reminders on a schedule, especially for long-running matters.
Override retention automatically
A hold must stop routine deletion immediately. If your retention schedule runs in one system and holds are tracked in another, there is a window where records can be lost.
Release deliberately
When the matter ends, release the hold formally and let normal retention resume. Records kept past their schedule because nobody released a hold are a cost, and a risk in the next matter.



